The Tender Caress of His Fist – Niggling Thoughts on a Reader’s Relationship with a Story

Jesus Wept.

A Short Story only requires two words. A subject/object and a verb. A short story draws on the author’s ability to elicit emotion and conjure up imagery. It also very strongly relies on the reader’s ability to fill in the gaps, drawing from recognition of history and culture reference.

A reader who has not learnt Christian tradition, not read the Gospels would not be moved by the words “Jesus Wept”. However, one who has, will draw upon the development of Jesus as a powerful prophet, the Messiah, a god – able to control nature and just days before the incident inferred able to raise a girl from the dead. And yet, here he is, faced with the death of his best friend, and his best friend’s weeping sisters – Jesus wept!


“I loved him with everything I had. He loved me back with the tender caress of his fist against my ribcage.” 

fist90% of my test readers attached violence to the fist in my creation above. This quotient felt that the ‘tender caress’ was a reference to ‘a punch’. Only 10% suggested that perhaps ‘he’ had callused hands and so chose to literally caress ‘her’ ribcage tenderly with his fist or rather ‘a closed hand’.

90% of my test readers assumed the ‘I’ was female. Only 10% hesitated and wondered if it could be a male.

Based on the comments & observations above, select a short story you wrote before, select a sentence in it, and imagine how, in the context of both your story and culture, a reader would interpret it.

Have fun imagining! Then think about it next time you spin that story.


2 thoughts on “The Tender Caress of His Fist – Niggling Thoughts on a Reader’s Relationship with a Story

  1. I am part of the 90% that thought twas a he, a violent he. And ofcourse Assumed the writer was male.
    I figure if I thought as a writer though, I would’ve reasoned like the 10%. At creation I seek to be different but as a reader I just expect the world to be what I’ve always assumed to be normal. (I don’t know if that makes any sense)

    P.s Sorry I took forever getting here.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.